Skip to main content
Penn State Altoona
Report a Concern Give Visit Apply
  • Academics
    • Majors
    • Academic Calendar
    • Research and Engagement
    • Eiche Library
    • Registrar
    • Academic Advising
    • Honors Program
    • Out-of-Class Learning
    • New Student Orientation
    • Commencement
  • Admissions & Financial Aid
    • Visit Us
    • Admissions Overview
    • Information for First-Year Students
    • How to Apply
    • Accepted Students
    • Find Your Admissions Counselor
    • Tuition and Financial Aid Resources
    • Financial Aid Basics
    • Tuition and Costs
  • Student Success
    • Student Success Center
    • The Help Tool
    • Tutoring
    • Student Affairs
    • Student and Civic Engagement
    • Health and Wellness
    • Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging
    • Safety at Penn State Altoona
    • Career Services
    • Eiche Library
  • Information For
    • Prospective Students
    • Transfer Students
    • Current Students
    • International Students
    • High School Dual Enrollment Program
    • Faculty & Staff
    • Alumni
    • Parents & Families
    • Professional Development
    • Visitors
Full site navigation menu

This dialog contains the full navigation menu for this site.

Penn State Altoona
Enter the terms you wish to search for.
Search type:
Report a Concern Give Visit Apply
  • This is Penn State Altoona
    • Welcome from the Chancellor
    • Penn State Altoona At a Glance
    • Mission, Vision, and Values
    • College Leadership
    • Our History
    • Campus Map
    • Current Weather Conditions
    • Livestream
  • Academics
    • Majors
    • Academic Calendar
    • Out-of-class Learning
    • Eiche Library
    • Registrar
    • Academic Advising
    • Honors Program
    • Campus Closures
  • Admissions
    • Visit Us
    • Information for First-Year Students
    • How to Apply
    • Accepted Students
    • Find Your Admissions Counselor
    • Experience Altoona
    • Virtual Tour
  • Tuition and Financial Aid
    • Scholarships and Awards
    • Grants
    • Loans
    • Work-study
    • Financial Aid Basics
    • Tuition and Costs
    • Financial Aid Information
  • Student Success
    • Student Success Center
    • The Help Tool
    • Tutoring
    • Student Affairs
    • Student Leadership and Involvement
    • Health and Wellness Center
    • Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging
    • Internships
    • Safety at Penn State Altoona
    • Study Abroad/Study Away
  • Research and Engagement
    • Undergraduate Research and Creative Inquiry
    • Faculty Research Resources
    • Internal Grants and Awards
  • Athletics
    • Schedule
    • Facilities
    • Recreation and Club Sports
    • Staff and Coaches Directory
    • Athletic Training and Sports Physicals
    • Athletics News
    • Camps and Clinics
    • Hall of Fame

Find Information For:

  • Prospective Students
  • Transfer Students
  • Current Students
  • International Students
  • High School Dual Enrollment Program
  • Faculty & Staff
  • Alumni
  • Parents & Families
  • Professional Development
  • Visitors

Helpful Links

  • Campus Map
  • Academic Calendar
  • Campus Calendar
  • Community Calendar
  • Student Success Center
  • The Help Tool
  • Faculty & Staff Directory
  • Offices and Divisions
  • Employment Opportunities

Connect With Us

  • facebook
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • linkedin
  • tiktok
  1. Home
  2. Offices and Divisions
  3. Academic Affairs
  4. Faculty Handbooks and Policies

Grade Mediation and Adjudication Procedures

University Faculty Senate Policy 47-20 Basis for Grades

Grades shall be assigned to individual students on the basis of the instructor’s judgment of the student’s scholastic achievement as set forth in Section 47-60. The instructor should provide written (paper or electronic form) notification of the basis for grades to students on or before the first class meeting. Any changes in that basis should likewise be presented to students in writing.

For grade assignments related to cases of academic dishonesty, refer to Section 49-20 (sanction on grades) and G-9 academic integrity procedures.

AAPPM — G-10: Grade Mediation and Adjudication

  1. Occasionally, a disagreement arises in the assignment of a grade. A student who wishes to question or challenge the grade assigned in a course must first discuss grading practices and assignments with the instructor. It is expected that the student and instructor will try to eliminate any misunderstandings and will attempt to work out any disagreements over grades. Some examples of the basis for a legitimate disagreement could include, but are not limited to the following:
    • The instructor did not inform the student of the basis for calculation of grades as required in 47-20.
    • The instructor did not calculate the student's grade in accordance with the instructor's stated policy for calculating grades.
    • There is an error in the computation of the grade that was not corrected.
    • The student, through no fault of their own, was not provided with the same opportunity to complete the requirements for the course in terms, for example, of time, access to materials, or access to the instructor as the other students.
  2. If the meeting with the instructor fails to resolve the issue, the student contacts the appropriate Division Head to arrange mediation. The Division Head will arrange a meeting with student and instructor to mediate dispute.
  3. If the issue is still not resolved, the student is directed to the Vice Chancellor for Academic Affairs. The Vice Chancellor will request that the student to put their concerns about the grade into writing, and will also request information from the instructor, including a copy of the syllabus, an indication of any changes to the syllabus and whether or not they were made in writing (with copies of written notification), a list of the student's grades for each assignment with indication of their relative weight and the final grade, and a statement about any other factors which impacted on the grade, such as attendance, late assignments, participation, academic integrity, etc. The Vice Chancellor will also request a statement from the Division Head about efforts to mediate dispute, including an indication of key issues or problems. A meeting will then be arranged with the Vice Chancellor, student, and instructor to mediate the dispute.
  4. If the issue is still not resolved, the student must complete the Grade Adjudication Petition Form and turn this into the office of the Vice Chancellor. This form must be turned into the Vice Chancellor's office no later than the Friday of 5th week of the semester following the semester in which the disputed grade was received. To obtain a form, please contact Peter Moran, W110 Smith, 814-949-5283, [email protected].
  5. The Vice Chancellor will review the petition to determine if the student's complaint provides evidence that the instructor's assignment of the grade is in violation of Senate Policy 47-20 and may decide that the petition does not meet the criteria for grade adjudication. In such cases, the grade will stand.

    If the Vice Chancellor believes that the student's petition does meet the criteria for grade adjudication, the Vice Chancellor may solicit additional information from the instructor. If upon review of the instructor's response the Vice Chancellor concludes that the grade assignment does not conform to Senate Policy 47-20, the Vice Chancellor will determine a course of action that may include a recommendation for an amended grade. The instructor must respond within ten days. The Vice Chancellor will then provide the student and the instructor with notification of the instructor's response and a brief summary of the reasons for the decision.
  6. The student or the instructor may appeal the recommendation of the Vice Chancellor to the Chancellor of the College within 10 days of receipt. If neither the student nor the instructor wishes to appeal the decision, and the grade assignment was found to conform with Senate Policy 47-20, the grade will stand.

    If neither the student nor the instructor wishes to appeal the recommendation, and the grade assignment was found to violate Senate Policy 47-20, the Vice Chancellor will determine an appropriate grade or appoint an ad hoc committee of 2-3 faculty with appropriate disciplinary expertise. The ad hoc committee will recommend a grade. The Vice Chancellor will notify the student and instructor of the recommended grade change and the supporting rationale in accordance with Senate Policy 47-20. The recommended grade change will be provided by the Vice Chancellor to the Dean of the college for transmittal to the University Registrar.
  7. If either the student or instructor wishes to appeal the recommendation of the Vice Chancellor, however, the petition and any relevant findings of the Vice Chancellor will be forwarded to the Chancellor of the college offering the course.

    If the Chancellor finds that the grade assignment does conform to Senate Policy 47-20, the original grade assignment will stand.

    If the Chancellor finds that the grade assignment does not conform with Senate Policy 47-20, the Chancellor will appoint an ad hoc committee of 2-3 faculty with appropriate disciplinary expertise to determine and recommend a grade. The Chancellor will then determine the grade and transmit it to the Registrar.

Academic Affairs

  • Request Information about Academic Affairs
  • Academic Integrity
    • Academic Integrity System User Guide for Instructors
    • Academic Integrity System User Guide for Students
  • Faculty Handbooks and Policies
    • Faculty Leaves of Absence
    • Faculty Workload Policy
    • Field Trip Request Procedures
    • Foreign Language Course Substitution Policy
    • Grade Mediation and Adjudication Procedures
    • Guidelines for Faculty Consulting Agreements
    • Guidelines for University Classroom Improvement Fund Proposals
    • Internship and Independent Study Compensation Guidelines
  • Promotion and Tenure
  • Baccalaureate Degree Program Guide
  • Academic Affairs Leadership and Office Staff
  • All Academic Affairs Faculty and Staff
  • Opening Week Calendar of Events
  • Faculty and Staff Conference
  • STAR Series
  • Fall 2024 New Faculty
  • Promotion and Tenure 2024

Academic Affairs

Elm Building
814-949-5756

HOURS
Monday–Friday
8:00 a.m.–5:00 p.m.

Research and Teaching at Penn State Altoona

An online magazine highlighting research, teaching, scholarship, and creative activity

Read It Now
Pennsylvania map showing Penn State's campuses with Penn State Altoona highlighted

Penn State Altoona

A full-service, four-year, residential campus located less than 45 miles from the research campus at University Park. Offering 21 four-year degrees and the first two years of over 275 Penn State majors.
  • facebook
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • linkedin
  • tiktok
Give Visit Apply
  • This is Penn State Altoona
    • Welcome from the Chancellor
    • Penn State Altoona At a Glance
    • Mission, Vision, and Values
    • College Leadership
    • Our History
    • Campus Map
    • Current Weather Conditions
    • Livestream
  • Academics
    • Majors
    • Academic Calendar
    • Out-of-Class Learning
    • Eiche Library
    • Registrar
    • Academic Advising
    • Honors Program
    • Campus Closures
  • Admissions
    • Visit Us
    • Information for First-Year Students
    • How to Apply
    • Accepted Students
    • Find Your Admissions Counselor
    • Experience Altoona
    • Virtual Tour
  • Tuition & Financial Aid
    • Scholarships and Awards
    • Grants
    • Loans
    • Work-study
    • Financial Aid Basics
    • Tuition and Costs
    • Financial Aid Information
  • Student Success
    • Student Success Center
    • The Help Tool
    • Tutoring
    • Student Affairs
    • Student and Civic Engagement
    • Health and Wellness Center
    • Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging
    • Safety at Penn State Altoona
    • Career Services
    • Eiche Library
  • Research & Engagement
    • Undergraduate Research and Creative Inquiry
    • Faculty Research Resources
    • Internships
    • Study Abroad/Study Away
    • Internal Grants and Awards
  • Athletics
    • Schedule
    • Facilities
    • Recreation and Club Sports
    • Staff and Coaches Directory
    • Athletic Training and Sports Physicals
    • Athletics News
    • Camps and Clinics
    • Hall of Fame
  • Stay Connected
    • Faculty and Staff Directory
    • Offices and Divisions
    • Campus Calendar
    • PSUAlert Text Messaging Service
    • Penn State Altoona Connect
    • Penn State Go App
    • Penn State Student Engagement Network
Penn State University
3000 Ivyside Park, Altoona, Pennsylvania 16601 814-949-5000

Footer Legal Menu

  • Privacy
  • Non-discrimination
  • Accessibility
  • Copyright
  • Directory
  • The Pennsylvania State University © 2025
  • We Are Penn State