Skip to main content
Penn State Altoona
Report a Concern Give Visit Apply
  • Academics
    • Majors
    • Academic Calendar
    • Research and Engagement
    • Eiche Library
    • Registrar
    • Academic Advising
    • Honors Program
    • Out-of-Class Learning
    • New Student Orientation
    • Commencement
  • Admissions & Financial Aid
    • Visit Us
    • Admissions Overview
    • Information for First-Year Students
    • How to Apply
    • Accepted Students
    • Find Your Admissions Counselor
    • Tuition and Financial Aid Resources
    • Financial Aid Basics
    • Tuition and Costs
  • Student Success
    • Student Success Center
    • The Help Tool
    • Tutoring
    • Student Affairs
    • Student and Civic Engagement
    • Health and Wellness
    • Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging
    • Safety at Penn State Altoona
    • Career Services
    • Eiche Library
  • Information For
    • Prospective Students
    • Transfer Students
    • Current Students
    • International Students
    • High School Dual Enrollment Program
    • Faculty & Staff
    • Alumni
    • Parents & Families
    • Professional Development
    • Visitors
Full site navigation menu

This dialog contains the full navigation menu for this site.

Penn State Altoona
Enter the terms you wish to search for.
Search type:
Report a Concern Give Visit Apply
  • This is Penn State Altoona
    • Welcome from the Chancellor
    • Penn State Altoona At a Glance
    • Mission, Vision, and Values
    • College Leadership
    • Our History
    • Campus Map
    • Current Weather Conditions
    • Livestream
  • Academics
    • Majors
    • Academic Calendar
    • Out-of-class Learning
    • Eiche Library
    • Registrar
    • Academic Advising
    • Honors Program
    • Campus Closures
  • Admissions
    • Visit Us
    • Information for First-Year Students
    • How to Apply
    • Accepted Students
    • Find Your Admissions Counselor
    • Experience Altoona
    • Virtual Tour
  • Tuition and Financial Aid
    • Scholarships and Awards
    • Grants
    • Loans
    • Work-study
    • Financial Aid Basics
    • Tuition and Costs
    • Financial Aid Information
  • Student Success
    • Student Success Center
    • The Help Tool
    • Tutoring
    • Student Affairs
    • Student Leadership and Involvement
    • Health and Wellness Center
    • Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging
    • Internships
    • Safety at Penn State Altoona
    • Study Abroad/Study Away
  • Research and Engagement
    • Undergraduate Research and Creative Inquiry
    • Faculty Research Resources
    • Internal Grants and Awards
  • Athletics
    • Schedule
    • Facilities
    • Recreation and Club Sports
    • Staff and Coaches Directory
    • Athletic Training and Sports Physicals
    • Athletics News
    • Camps and Clinics
    • Hall of Fame

Find Information For:

  • Prospective Students
  • Transfer Students
  • Current Students
  • International Students
  • High School Dual Enrollment Program
  • Faculty & Staff
  • Alumni
  • Parents & Families
  • Professional Development
  • Visitors

Helpful Links

  • Campus Map
  • Academic Calendar
  • Campus Calendar
  • Community Calendar
  • Student Success Center
  • The Help Tool
  • Faculty & Staff Directory
  • Offices and Divisions
  • Employment Opportunities

Connect With Us

  • facebook
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • linkedin
  • tiktok
  1. Home
  2. Offices and Divisions
  3. Academic Affairs
  4. Common Read
  5. Reflections on "Exit West"

Lovers' Journey in Reverse: A Found Poem

By Bethany McCarl


Found Poems from Exit West

(From page 45) #1

Nadia led Saeed.

He felt.

She sat.

Aren’t you going to take that off?

You first.

Together, then.

Together.

(From page 64) #2

They smoked.

They pleasured.

His head rested.

“You want to get married?”

“To me?”

“To you.”

She felt great tenderness.

She felt

terror.

She felt

complicated,

resentment,

“I don’t know.”

(From page 136) #3

They sat.

He extended a hand.

She took it.

Promise.

I do.

They felt closer.

They had been born.

(From page 153) #4

We’ve left.

We have no connection.

Apart.

No answer.

Despite the horrors,

he had felt.

She had felt.

They had felt together.

(From page 186) #5

Saeed and Nadia

found themselves changed.

A man of substance.

She felt strangely unmoved,

without desire.

(From page 187-188) #6

He believed he loved her.

Resentment

made him angry.

He wanted to feel.

Loss

left him unmoored.

He cared,

wanted to protect.

She was family.

He hoped.

They were better.

(From page 230) #7

Beside one another

under the sky.

They looked,

they spoke.

Two lives.

Former lovers,

not wounded.

Together.

Imagine how different life would be.

Imagine how different it would be.


What is a “found poem?”

“Found poems take existing texts and refashion them, reorder them, and present them as poems. The literary equivalent of a collage, found poetry is often made from newspaper articles, street signs, graffiti, speeches, letters, or even other poems.”

Artist Statement-2018: Bethany McCarl

I have always found poetry in small things. I find poetry in the way leaves move in the wind. How they change colors and fall to the ground and are born again. I find poetry in the way a mother bird makes a nest from what humans call dirt and sticks and provides a shelter for her babies, until they are able to fly on their own. I find poetry in the way a dog will wait at the door for her owner all day. Poetry is all around us in everything that happens in life. You just need to have the eyes and heart to find it. In Hamid’s Exist West, poetry is all over the pages, so I did not reorganize any of the words to make my series of found poems; the poems were already made. Hamid’s words are so powerful and heartfelt that all I had to do was pick my favorite ones.

The story of Nadia and Saeed’s relationship is what I call a “journey in reverse” due to the fact that they start out as passionate lovers, but, instead of progressing in that relationship, become increasingly like brother and sister to each other. I find their love story to be both heartbreaking and beautiful simultaneously. They start out very passionate, timid in a sensual way, and find themselves hoping to get married one day. As their relationship develops, their passion grows. But as their migratory experiences get increasingly difficult, they find themselves falling out of that passion with one another. Their love they retain, though it evolves into something different, something that emerges from living in their city of blackness, to losing Saeed’s mother and leaving Saeed’s father behind, to migrating time and time again. While much is lost and destroyed, they find family in each other. I think they do not want to risk losing another member of their family, so they stop the romance and accept the fact that their love has changed into a protective and bonded sort of love.

We all have love stories of our own. Hamid’s novel reminded me of a love I had lost, but also a love I have found. It awoke the sleeping poet within me, with the natural flow of its words, and the raw, intense relationship between Nadia and Saeed. It is important to read books that make you feel. Now I will always have this novel to reopen, in case the poet inside of me falls asleep again.

Common Read

  • Reflections on "Almost American Girl"
    • Emma R. Moniz
    • Anthony Palacios
    • Maeve Watson
  • Reflections on "Ghostographs"
    • The Most Dangerous Game
    • Reflecting on "Tess"
    • Look Into the Light
  • Reflections on "Exit West"
    • "Exit West," Give it a Chance
    • "Exit West:" An Anecdote of Undeniable Relevance
    • Questions for Mohsin Hamid
    • Borders, Doors, Responsibilities: A Common Read Event Not to Miss!
    • Lovers' Journey in Reverse: A Found Poem
  • Common Read Selection Archive

Common Read Events

×
Pennsylvania map showing Penn State's campuses with Penn State Altoona highlighted

Penn State Altoona

A full-service, four-year, residential campus located less than 45 miles from the research campus at University Park. Offering 21 four-year degrees and the first two years of over 275 Penn State majors.
  • facebook
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • linkedin
  • tiktok
Give Visit Apply
  • This is Penn State Altoona
    • Welcome from the Chancellor
    • Penn State Altoona At a Glance
    • Mission, Vision, and Values
    • College Leadership
    • Our History
    • Campus Map
    • Current Weather Conditions
    • Livestream
  • Academics
    • Majors
    • Academic Calendar
    • Out-of-Class Learning
    • Eiche Library
    • Registrar
    • Academic Advising
    • Honors Program
    • Campus Closures
  • Admissions
    • Visit Us
    • Information for First-Year Students
    • How to Apply
    • Accepted Students
    • Find Your Admissions Counselor
    • Experience Altoona
    • Virtual Tour
  • Tuition & Financial Aid
    • Scholarships and Awards
    • Grants
    • Loans
    • Work-study
    • Financial Aid Basics
    • Tuition and Costs
    • Financial Aid Information
  • Student Success
    • Student Success Center
    • The Help Tool
    • Tutoring
    • Student Affairs
    • Student and Civic Engagement
    • Health and Wellness Center
    • Diversity, Equity, Inclusion, and Belonging
    • Safety at Penn State Altoona
    • Career Services
    • Eiche Library
  • Research & Engagement
    • Undergraduate Research and Creative Inquiry
    • Faculty Research Resources
    • Internships
    • Study Abroad/Study Away
    • Internal Grants and Awards
  • Athletics
    • Schedule
    • Facilities
    • Recreation and Club Sports
    • Staff and Coaches Directory
    • Athletic Training and Sports Physicals
    • Athletics News
    • Camps and Clinics
    • Hall of Fame
  • Stay Connected
    • Faculty and Staff Directory
    • Offices and Divisions
    • Campus Calendar
    • PSUAlert Text Messaging Service
    • Penn State Altoona Connect
    • Penn State Go App
    • Penn State Student Engagement Network
Penn State University
3000 Ivyside Park, Altoona, Pennsylvania 16601 814-949-5000

Footer Legal Menu

  • Privacy
  • Non-discrimination
  • Accessibility
  • Copyright
  • Directory
  • The Pennsylvania State University © 2025
  • We Are Penn State